Harness vs. Collar: Which Reigns Supreme in Britain?

Harness vs. Collar: Which Reigns Supreme in Britain?

A classic British dilemma, somewhat akin to the age-old debate of 'tea vs. coffee', revolves around the canine world: Should you opt for a collar or a harness for your furry friend?

For the discerning dog owner, this isn't just a matter of fashion but of functionality, safety, and comfort.

As we stroll through UK parks, from London's Hyde Park to Edinburgh's Holyrood Park, we notice a mix; some dogs sport stylish collars, while others don chic harnesses.

Let's embark on a journey to unravel this debate and arm you with the knowledge you need to make the best decision for your pup.

Brief History

Historically, the dog collar has its roots steeped in ancient civilisations, where it was used both as a means of control and a symbol of ownership. Egyptian hieroglyphs depict dogs with collars, showcasing their importance even then.

On British soil, dog collars became a status symbol in the medieval period, with intricate designs and even embellishments for the more affluent dogs. Fast forward to the 20th century, the dog harness emerged as a preferred choice for specific activities like sledging and tracking.

It was soon recognised for its health and control benefits, and thus began its rise in popularity across the UK's cobbled streets and countryside trails.

The Time-Honoured Dog Collar: Advantages and Considerations

The classic dog collar remains a quintessential item for British canine enthusiasts. Its long-standing popularity isn't without reason:


Simplicity: Collars offer an uncomplicated and swift solution for those impromptu strolls during rare sunny spells.

Legal Requirement: In the UK, dogs are legally required to wear a collar with an inscribed tag displaying the owner's name and address while in public spaces. It’s an assured way of reuniting with your pet if they wander off.

Training Resource: Collars can serve as a practical tool for behaviour correction in dogs with gentler dispositions, guiding them with a subtle nudge.


Pressure on the Neck: Collars exert force directly on the neck, which can be problematic for dogs prone to respiratory issues or those with a predisposition to conditions like tracheal collapse.

Potential for Pulling: Eager pups might feel inclined to tug harder when held by a collar, which could pose challenges during walks.

Safety Concerns: In situations where a dog gets caught on something, a collar might pose a choking risk, especially if it isn't a breakaway design.

The collar's legacy in dog ownership is undisputed, but it's essential to assess its fit and appropriateness for your individual pet.

Embracing the Modern Harness: Benefits and Drawbacks

Harnesses have certainly carved a niche for themselves among UK dog lovers, offering a refreshing blend of safety and functionality. Here's a breakdown of their pros and cons:


Distribution of Pressure: Harnesses evenly distribute pressure over a broader body area, reducing the strain on the neck. This is especially beneficial for breeds susceptible to tracheal conditions.

Enhanced Control: For dogs that are a tad too enthusiastic about their surroundings, harnesses offer optimal control, curbing their urge to chase every squirrel in sight.

Puppy-Friendly: The vulnerable necks of young pups are shielded, making it an ideal choice during their formative months.

Car Safety: Several harness designs can double as safety restraints for car journeys, ensuring your pet's safety during those drives to the coast.


Complexity: Some harness designs might be a tad intricate, taking a bit longer to put on, especially if you have a wriggly pooch.

Incorrect Fitting: A poorly-fitted harness can lead to chafing or might not provide the benefits it promises.

Over-reliance: Relying solely on a harness might not encourage good leash behaviour, as some dogs feel they can pull more.

While harnesses bring a plethora of advantages to the table, it's vital to select a design tailored to your dog's size, breed, and activity

Making the Right Choice: Factors to Consider for Your Canine Companion

Every dog is a unique individual, much like us humans. When debating between a collar and a harness, it's not a one-size-fits-all answer. Let's delve into what should influence your decision:

Dog's Health & Physical Needs:

Existing Medical Issues: Dogs with respiratory problems or conditions like tracheal collapse might benefit more from harnesses.

Age: Puppies, with their developing structures, might find harnesses more accommodating, while older dogs with arthritis or mobility issues could require specific types of support.

Behavioural Traits:

Pulling Tendency: Dogs that are natural pullers or are overly enthusiastic might be better managed with a harness.

Training Stage: If you're in the process of training your dog, you might lean towards a collar for correction, but switch to a harness for general walks.

Intended Activity:

Adventure Walks: If you're planning to tread uneven terrains, a harness can offer better stability.

Casual Strolls: For short, relaxed walks around the neighbourhood, a simple collar might suffice.

Comfort & Fit:

Proper Sizing: Whether you opt for a collar or harness, ensure it fits snugly, avoiding any chafing or restriction.

Quality: A high-quality material that's breathable and durable will ensure your dog's comfort and the product's longevity.

Remember, it's about your dog's comfort, safety, and your peace of mind. Observe their reactions to each, and perhaps even consult your local vet or a dog behaviourist to make an informed choice.

Beyond Functionality: The Aesthetic and Personalisation Possibilities

Your dog's collar or harness is not just a tool – it's a statement. In an age where pet fashion has grown in leaps and bounds, how your dog looks and feels in their gear matters. Here's what you should consider when thinking aesthetics and personalisation:

Material & Design:

Fabric Choices: From leather to nylon, the material can set the tone. For instance, a sleek leather harness might give a regal feel, while a patterned fabric one could be more fun and playful.

Colour Variations: Pick a shade that complements your dog's coat. The contrast can make their fur pop!

Personalisation Features:

Name Tags & Embroidery: Some brands offer personalisation services where your dog's name or a special message can be embroidered onto the collar or harness.

Accessory Attachments: Charms, badges, or even GPS trackers can be added to some models, turning a basic collar or harness into a multifunctional accessory.

Staying Updated:

Trending Styles: Just like human fashion, dog accessories have trends. Whether it's a seasonal pattern or a new design breakthrough, staying updated can let your pup sport the latest styles.

Remember, while looking stylish is fantastic, never compromise on comfort. Your dog's well-being should always come first, and with brands like HUNTER, you never have to choose between style and substance.

Superiority in Collars and Harnesses

When selecting the perfect accessory for your furry friend, it’s essential to opt for products that offer both impeccable style and unmatched functionality. Hunter has always stood at the intersection of luxury and practicality. Here's what distinguishes Hunter's collars and harnesses from the rest:

Exceptional Material:

Leather Excellence: Our collars, like the Hunter Cannes Leather Collar, blend sophistication with durability, promising a timeless appeal.

Breathable Fabrics: The Hunter Brighton Harness integrates lightweight materials to ensure comfort during prolonged wear.

Meticulous Craftsmanship:

Precision and Care: Every stitch in the Hunter Urban Dog Harness, for instance, is a testament to our meticulous attention to detail.

Reinforced Design: Features such as double-stitched boundaries and robust metal clasps underscore the strength and longevity of our products.

Unwavering Reputation:

A Community’s Endorsement: The word-of-mouth from our trusted community speaks volumes about the longevity and quality of our products.

The Hunter Seal: Our ongoing commitment to quality ensures every dog owner can trust the lasting nature of our collars and harnesses.

Investing in Hunter means prioritising your dog's comfort, safety, and style. With our curated collection, your pup is not just accessorised but celebrated.

Making the Right Choice for Your Pup

Choosing between a collar and a harness is about understanding your dog's needs, temperament, and activities. Both collars and harnesses come with their own set of benefits and potential drawbacks. Ultimately, it's about what aligns best with your dog's comfort and safety. Whether it's the unrestricted freedom of a collar or the supportive embrace of a harness, the best decision is an informed one. Spend time observing your dog, consulting with a vet, and trying out both options to discern which accessory will offer the optimal experience for your canine companion.

Back to blog